|This is a smirk. |
And from what I know of this character,
he probably just kissed his brother's girlfriend
or killed someone's best friend.
Not a nice smile.
To Smirk or Not To Smirk
To me, a smirk is cocky, smug, or cruel. At the very least, it's a teasing sort of smile, or a "hah! I got you!" Smirking is what the bad guy does as he pulls one over on your hero, not what your hero does when he tells the heroine that he loves her.
But after so many counterexamples, I thought maybe I had my definition wrong. So I looked it up.
Oxford: "to smile in an irritatingly smug, conceited, or silly way."
Merriam-Webster: "to smile in an unpleasant way because you are pleased with yourself, glad about someone else's trouble, etc."
Apparently back in the day it used to mean simply "to smile," but we're not back in the day, and even if you're writing historical fiction, it's a dangerous game to use an old definition of a word that now has quite a different meaning.
Other Smiling Words
I've come across the same thing with grin. To me, a grin is a big, face-scrunching smile, usually silly, mischievous, humorous, or teasing. It's not the kind of thing you usually do in, for example, a sentimental or bittersweet moment.
Synonyms for 'laugh' can cause problems too. If your tough manly man giggles, that's interesting characterization. Maybe he's really a little girl at heart. Maybe he gets nervous easily in unfamiliar situations. But you'd better mean it if you use it. If a character guffaws at something that's not so funny to the reader, you might lose credibility. Unless, of course, over-laughter is part of his personality. Again, great characterization--but only if you mean it that way.
I read a book where no one walked anywhere. Instead, everyone paced. They paced to the door, paced across the street, paced to each other. And I don't think they ever actually walked back and forth, which is what I think of as pacing. It was almost as if the author had been told not to use "boring" words like 'walk.' This author also rarely wrote 'small' or 'little,' replacing them instead with 'minute.' By the end, I was almost throwing things at my Kindle and yelling, "Stop pacing, you minute boy!"
There are many, many sort-of synonyms for walk: stroll, stride, saunter, amble, trudge, plod, hike, tramp, march, stride, wander, ramble, tread, promenade, roam, traipse, take the air; advance, proceed, mosey, perambulate, etc, etc..
They all mean different things, and most can be good--in the right place. But if you start using one over and over--especially if it conveys the wrong meaning, you risk annoying your reader. And don't ever use "perambulate" unless you mean it to be funny.
Gaze, glance, gape, stare, peer, peek, watch, examine, inspect, scan, scrutinize, consider, observe, ogle, espy, etc., etc.
Again, most can be good in moderation, but the current book I'm reading had a line like this: "He glimpsed up quickly." No...to glimpse is to catch a quick look at something, usually before it disappears or you move past it. You can't glimpse up. Then there was this: "He glanced one eye over his shoulder." 'Glance' is intransitive (has no direct object). You can't glance something. You have to simply glance.
Don't even get me started. Maybe I'll explore this subject next time. I'll just say now that if you use a dialogue tag like "admonished" or "theorized" more than once or twice in a book, reconsider. And if you insist on using lots of unusual synonyms for 'said,' make sure the meaning really fits the dialogue. Don't just use a word you randomly pointed at on your "synonyms for said" cheat sheet.
Using Synonyms (plying, wielding, manipulating...)
Just because there is a synonym doesn't mean you should automatically use it, just to cut repetition or avoid "boring" words. Be sure that the synonym means what you think it means and that it won't make your reader think you're joking. (Ascertain that the synonym signifies what you postulate that it betokens and that it will not induce the peruser to opine that you're jesting.) And generally only use words that are in your active vocabulary. Else the danger is too high that you'll misuse them.
Obviously, styles differ, and if yours is more flowery, more of these types of words might fit. Sometimes you can play with definitions and stretch words for creativity's sake. But you have to do it intentionally...and carefully.
How to Avoid the Issue
Perhaps the real problem is that we often write too many of these types of words to begin with. A critiquer friend of mine calls them "stage directions": all the looking, laughing, nodding, smiling words. Maybe it's best to simply cut down on them altogether. Then we won't have to rely on innacurate or laughable synonyms.
Melinda Brasher currently teaches English as a second language in the beautiful Czech Republic. She loves the sound of glaciers calving and the smell of old books. Her travel articles and short fiction appear in Go Nomad, International Living, Electric Spec, Intergalactic Medicine Show, and others. For an e-book collection of some of her favorite published pieces, check out Leaving Home. For something a little more medieval, read her YA fantasy novel, Far-Knowing. Visit her online at http://www.melindabrasher.com.